newspapers

  • Dead dog foils poison plot - really bad journalism

    I found this story in the Citizen last week (please don't ask why I was reading it) when I came across this wonderful story that was just too good to be true. The story has been given a great South African flavour but sadly it is a variation of one of the oldest urban legends ever - Snopes.com has a version dating back to 1946

    A DEAD dog was at the centre of a huge rumpus last week which involved faction fights, police, ambulances, the local municipal disaster management service and the regional hospital.

    It could only have happened in Zululand, and it’s no urban legend

    The story began on Friday afternoon when a cow with a broken leg was found in a ditch at a rural settlement.

    The suffering animal was mercifully killed and preparation was made by its owners for the community to feast on the meat.However, it was pointed out that the beast had been returning from the direction of the opposing faction when it landed in the ditch.

    Fears were expressed that the other group may have poisoned the cow and deliberately set up the accident, knowing that the animal would end up on the plates of their enemy.Grey heads decided that a portion of the meat be given to a dog: if it survived, they could all feast to their hearts’ content.

    The mongrel did indeed survive the night and Saturday saw the party proceed in full swing...until a child reported that the dog was dead.Panic set in, with the group of about 60 rushing for traditional herbs and swallowing water from a dirty stream to induce vomiting.KZN Ambulance Services were summoned and Ngwelezana Hospital was placed on standby.The municipal disaster truck was brought in and police reinforcements arrived to assist the on-duty members.

    At some point in the chaos and fear, someone thought to ask where the dog was - no doubt, so that the type of poison used might be identified. Upon being called in for questioning, the same child said the dog was ‘still lying in the road where the vehicle struck it’!

    The government official who passed the facts of story on to the Zululand Observer could not say whether the feast continued after the child’s revelation.
    Be that as it may, we are sure our readers will feast on this true tale for many a year.

    Dave Savides - Zululand Observer

    I could not find the original story on the citizen website (great search function guys!), but I managed to find a google cached copy from the website of the Zululand Observer. IANAJ, but isn't there some kind of code of conduct against printing blatant untruths, even in a small regional paper. It took me less than 30 seconds to find out that the story was not true. At the very least the Citizen should have checked their facts before printing the story.

    I am really disappointed that it is not a true story - the South African angle almost makes it believable, and it is by far the best version of the urban legend that I have read. It would make a really funny short film - someone should make it.

  • A hell of a cup of tea

    I wasn't drunk at all...I had been with one of my colleagues earlier that night drinking tea.

    Judge Nkola Motata, quoted on IOL - High Court judge held for drunk driving (7 January 2007)

    That must have been a hell of a cup of tea:

    Prosecutor Anna-Marie Morton said forensic results of Motata's blood test showed high levels of alcohol intake.

    "The results show substantial high levels of alcohol," she told the court.

    Morton declined to tell reporters outside the courtroom the blood alcohol percentage. "I cannot say how much," she said.

    IOL - High levels of alcohol in Motata's blood (13 March 2007)

    At least its a change from the regular "but I only had a beer and a half a glass of wine" excuse that the cops normally hear at roadblocks.

  • Fidentia, Moneyweb and the people

    Vincent Maher has a fascinating transcript up on his blog of an interview he did with Hilton Tarrent, the Moneyweb production editor. There are some interesting Q&A's regarding the redevelopment of Moneyweb and how they handle moderation of reader comments (always an issue on South African sites), but the really good stuff comes in when they start discussing the reader response to the recent Fidentia debacle, which Moneyweb has covered extensively:

    HT: The response by our readers has been unprecedented. We have spoken at length internally about it, because we were caught by surprise. a large chunk of our readers during the early days were Fidentia employees (there were 1100 of them)

    VM: Do you think this is because people were finding out things for the first time about the company they work for, but from an outside source?

    HT: Yes. That was definitely a major part of it. we pretty much know this because we had letters, emails, phone calls, comments under stories from staff members

    VM: So the Fidentia ship suddenly sprung a thousand leaks…

    VM: What was the feeling among your team as all of this was happening?

    HT: Yeah. One of our major achievements was to get a staff member to write for us from the inside (he also spoke to us on radio): Small voice inside Fidentia speaks

    Another highlight comes later on in the transcript:

    HT: I think the most interesting thing we saw was the creation of original content by our readers, who then posted this as comments

    VM: Like short articles?

    HT: There were those, but users were also creating images, they pinpointed Arthur Brown’s house on Google maps, etc and then posted these to imageshack, with the links posted as comments, here and here.

    These are really great examples of what happens when you let your users take part in the conversation. Hilton points out some of the problems they faced, such as readers impersonating other readers, requests for content to be deleted and the like, but by and large there was a huge positive effect for Moneyweb, and they managed to get leads and further insight into the developing story. People also used Moneyweb and the comments system in ways that Moneyweb had not anticipated, and instead of shutting down comments and restricting what people could do they ran with it and came out on top. Its a great lesson for any media organisation.

    Source: Vincent Maher - Media in Transition » Fidentia scandal sparks an excellent case study in social media on Moneyweb


Hi, I'm Jaxon Rice. By day I run a Johannesburg based web company called Soup and by night I am the frontman of the Diesel Whores. This is my personal blog. more...

Previous Posts

Dead dog foils poison plot - really bad journalism
24 Apr 07 | 3,562 Views
A hell of a cup of tea
15 Apr 07 | 3,443 Views
Fidentia, Moneyweb and the people
05 Mar 07 | 573 Views
Dead dog foils poison plot - really bad journalism
24 Apr 07 | 1 Comments
A hell of a cup of tea
15 Apr 07 | 0 Comments
Fidentia, Moneyweb and the people
05 Mar 07 | 0 Comments
Dead dog foils poison plot - really bad journalism
24 Apr 07 | 1 Comments
Fidentia, Moneyweb and the people
05 Mar 07 | 0 Comments
A hell of a cup of tea
15 Apr 07 | 0 Comments

Thought Leader

The latest posts from my weekly sporadic column at Thoughtleader.co.za

Side Notes

Interesting finds, articles and other web ephemera